Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

Does "we tell each other everything" include a friend's private news?

Relationships category photographRelationships

A friend told me she was considering a move and asked me not to tell the group until she'd spoken to people herself. Later, my husband asked how she was. I gave an ordinary answer and kept the possible move private.

He noticed I was being careful and said we'd always told each other everything. He thinks a confidence shared with him would still be safe because he wouldn't repeat it. I believe him. I hadn't understood our openness as permission to add another listener to something a friend specifically asked me to keep between us.

How do we talk about the distinction without making it sound like I trust my friend more than my husband? I want to be honest with him about my own life and reliable about information someone else has chosen to share.

Discussion

5 community replies

His ability to keep a confidence doesn't answer whether your friend agreed to tell him. Explain that the audience was part of the promise you made. You can trust his discretion and still respect the limit of the conversation you actually had.

Discuss what "everything" has meant to each of you. Sharing your own plans and worries may feel different from recounting another person's private news. If the rule was never explicit, don't assume either interpretation was deliberately concealed.

Be careful about creating a dramatic hint that you know something but cannot say it. That can turn an ordinary confidence into a puzzle between you. You can give a straightforward account of the catch-up without announcing the existence of a secret as evidence of your loyalty.

You could agree on a clearer approach for future confidences. If either of you feels unable to keep something solely between a friend and yourselves, say so before accepting that promise. Don't leave friends relying on one understanding while the household quietly operates another.

That doesn't mean listing every private conversation for your partner to decide whether it qualifies. The agreement needs to be usable in ordinary life. It can protect openness about your own choices without making someone else's news a test of the marriage.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships