Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does the Supreme Court declining a case mean it approved the ruling below?

Politics category photographPolitics

I’m editing a civic reading group’s discussion note. One sentence says the US Supreme Court “agreed with the lower court” because it denied a petition for certiorari. The writer thinks replacing that sentence would minimise the practical importance of the lower-court decision.

The Court’s current Rule 10 describes certiorari review as discretionary. Its opinion in Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70, 85 (1995) also explains that a denial of certiorari does not express a view on the merits. That is the narrow distinction I’m trying to preserve; I’m not treating every kind of Court order as interchangeable.

Would “the Court declined to review the decision” give readers enough information, with a separate sentence explaining the lower court’s ruling? How can I avoid implying either an endorsement or that the case had no consequences?

Discussion

5 community replies

Your proposed wording is clearer. Attribute the reasoning to the court that actually gave it, and describe the Supreme Court’s action separately. Neither sentence needs to do both jobs.

The writer has a fair concern about consequences. Give the lower-court outcome its own space rather than using an inaccurate Supreme Court endorsement to make it sound important.

Check the actual order before editing the note. Your explanation concerns a denial of certiorari; the word “rejected” in someone’s summary is too vague to establish what happened.

Wouldn’t “declined to review” sound as if the Court simply hadn’t got around to the case yet?

Add that it denied the petition for review, if that is what the order says. That describes a decision on the request without claiming a merits ruling. You can explain the outcome below without predicting further proceedings.

Join the discussion

More in Politics