Does the Supreme Court declining a case mean it approved the ruling below?
PoliticsI’m editing a civic reading group’s discussion note. One sentence says the US Supreme Court “agreed with the lower court” because it denied a petition for certiorari. The writer thinks replacing that sentence would minimise the practical importance of the lower-court decision.
The Court’s current Rule 10 describes certiorari review as discretionary. Its opinion in Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70, 85 (1995) also explains that a denial of certiorari does not express a view on the merits. That is the narrow distinction I’m trying to preserve; I’m not treating every kind of Court order as interchangeable.
Would “the Court declined to review the decision” give readers enough information, with a separate sentence explaining the lower court’s ruling? How can I avoid implying either an endorsement or that the case had no consequences?