Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does speaking at the UN General Assembly prove a delegation is a UN member?

Politics category photographPolitics

While watching a General Assembly discussion, our reading group treated every delegation that spoke as a UN member state. Someone then found a reference to a 'non-member observer' and thought it must be a mistake: if the delegation wasn't a member, how could it be taking part?

The UN library's guide to observer states and entities distinguishes membership from participation. It describes non-member observers and standing invitations to participate in the Assembly's work. A speech alone therefore isn't enough to establish membership.

I'm making a small table of who spoke, rather than a complete guide to every participant's procedural rights. Should I include the formal status beside the name? I want to avoid both calling everyone a member and suggesting that an observer's contribution isn't worth hearing.

Discussion

5 community replies

Add the status if membership is relevant to your table. A column labelled 'speaker' needn't quietly become a list of member states.

'Observer' doesn't have to mean an audience member silently watching from a gallery. Your source gives the group a better starting point for understanding participation.

I'd avoid ranking the arguments by status. Record who spoke and in what capacity, then assess the contribution on its content.

If the table later includes votes, we'd need more than a status label. Different kinds of participation shouldn't be treated as identical voting rights.

Agreed. Check the rights that apply in that body and the actual voting record before adding such a column. The point established here is narrower: taking part in a discussion doesn't, on its own, prove UN membership.

Join the discussion

More in Politics