Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Does sharing a competition link mean my neighbour can ask me not to enter?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour sent me a link to a local photography competition and asked whether I would help him choose between a few possible entries. I said I would look at his shortlist when it was ready.

After reading about the competition, I realised I would like to enter one of my own photographs too. When I told him, he said, 'I showed you that so you could help me, not compete against me.' He wants me to stay out of it.

I haven't seen his shortlist or submitted anything. I didn't promise not to enter, but I did offer to help, and I can see why he may now feel awkward about showing me his work.

How can I be fair about that offer without treating the link as a claim on the whole opportunity? I would be disappointed to withdraw my own interest, and I don't want to reassure him by pretending I know which of us is more likely to win.

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate the two questions. You can say you intend to submit your own photograph while asking whether he still wants your help with the shortlist. Don't assume that his answer to the second question has to be yes.

He may have expected an encouraging collaborator and is now imagining a rival. That disappointment is understandable even if you never agreed to stay out. Acknowledge the change without pretending he had asked for exclusivity at the start.

Don't reassure him that his pictures are better or that your entry won't affect his chances. You haven't seen his shortlist, and those promises wouldn't resolve the disagreement about whether you may take part.

You did agree to look at his shortlist. Could you honour that offer before working on your entry, so he doesn't feel the original request has simply been discarded?

Only if he's comfortable with that arrangement now. Timing the feedback first wouldn't remove his concern about sharing work with someone who is also entering. Offer to fulfil the promise, but let him choose another sounding board without treating that as a reason you must withdraw.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours