Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Does Scotland's right of access mean our dog walk should go through a field with calves?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour has proposed a route for a group dog walk in Scotland. One section goes through a field where we have seen cows with calves. When I asked for an alternative, he said responsible access rights meant we didn't have to avoid it and that our dogs were friendly.

The walk hasn't happened and invitations haven't gone out. The Scottish Outdoor Access Code's dog-walking guidance says not to take dogs into fields with calves, lambs or other young farm animals.

I want to change that section rather than rely on an assurance about our dogs. How do I make the request without turning a friendly walk into an argument about who understands access rights? I am not proposing that every field with livestock is automatically off limits; I am asking about this route and the young animals present.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the specific dog-walking guidance for fields with young animals. General support for responsible access doesn't settle whether this particular section is appropriate for a group with dogs.

'Friendly' doesn't answer the condition in the Code. I would keep the conversation about the route, rather than debate whether somebody's dog has good character or recall.

Can the group agree a suitable alternative before sending invitations? That is easier than arriving at the field and treating anyone who objects as the person delaying the outing.

The organiser may feel his planning is being criticised. Thank him for putting a walk together and offer to help check a different section against the current guidance and conditions.

That is a constructive offer if you have time. The alternative still needs checking; don't replace one assumption with another about the next field. Shared planning can preserve the outing without requiring everyone to accept the original route.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours