Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does parliamentary privilege cover an MP speaking at our local event?

Politics category photographPolitics

We're hosting a local discussion with a UK MP. A volunteer's proposed introduction says parliamentary privilege means our guest can speak freely at the event without being sued for what they say. I thought the protection concerned parliamentary proceedings, rather than following the person into any room where they speak.

The Commons MPs' Guide to Procedure describes protection for speech in proceedings of the House and warns that repeating something outside Parliament does not necessarily have the same protection. That seems a good reason to remove the blanket claim from our introduction, without trying to decide the legal position of any particular remark.

The volunteer worries that bringing this up will sound as though we expect the guest to make things up. I see a different issue: people could hear the introduction as saying the usual questions about evidence no longer matter. Even a protected statement would still need evidence if we were being asked to believe it.

Would you briefly explain the distinction at the start, or simply leave legal claims out of the welcome? How can we make room for firm questions without turning the introduction into a warning aimed at the speaker?

Discussion

5 community replies

The proposed introduction makes a legal assurance the organisers don't need to make. I'd replace it with the guest's role, the subject, and how audience questions will work. That gives people useful information immediately.

I'd separate protection from accuracy if someone raises it. Whether a statement can be challenged in a particular legal setting doesn't tell an audience whether the statement is well supported.

The volunteer may hear your correction as a comment on the guest's character. Show them the guide and keep the conversation about the wording. There's no need to predict what the MP might say.

I'd leave privilege out of the welcome entirely. An event introduction isn't the place to teach the boundary of a legal protection, especially when you aren't settling the position of any actual statement.

I'd usually do that too. If the incorrect assurance has already been sent to attendees, though, quietly deleting it from the welcome won't correct what they read. A short correction to that earlier message would be worth separating from the live introduction.

Join the discussion

More in Politics