Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Does 'packed' brown sugar mean I should press it into the measuring cup?

Food category photographFood

I'm measuring ingredients for cookies while my sister reads the recipe. It says a packed cup of brown sugar. I spooned the sugar in loosely because I'd just been told not to compress the flour, and she wants me to press it down and refill the gap.

The Home Baking Association's measurement lesson specifically treats brown sugar as an exception to lightly filling dry measuring cups. I hadn't realised the way I filled the cup was part of the amount.

Should I empty and measure that sugar again before we mix, rather than treating the level top as enough? I'd like to understand the instruction without turning every ingredient into a packing exercise.

Discussion

5 community replies

For the packed measure specified here, press the brown sugar into the dry cup, fill the space that opens up and level it. The measurement lesson distinguishes that from lightly filling a cup with other dry ingredients.

Your sister isn't necessarily asking for sweeter cookies. She's asking for the quantity described by the recipe, which includes the word packed.

If the recipe also gives a weight, you can use that weight directly. You don't need to shape the sugar into a cup first just to put it on the scale.

I'd leave it loose because I prefer cookies less sweet.

That's a choice to adapt the sugar amount, rather than a different way to measure the same amount. Make that decision together and note it, so you don't later judge the recipe as though you used its packed cup.

Join the discussion

More in Food