Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does my second preference compete with my first in an Australian House election?

Politics category photographPolitics

A friend explained Australian federal House of Representatives voting by saying my second preference would give another candidate a vote against my first choice straight away. That made ranking the remaining candidates sound like undoing my first preference.

The AEC’s explanation of the House count starts with first preferences. If nobody has a majority, the candidate with the fewest votes is excluded and those ballots transfer according to their next preferences; exclusions and transfers continue as needed. My second preference is not an additional simultaneous vote against my first choice while that first choice remains in the count.

I want to explain that without giving anybody candidate advice or claiming this description covers Senate counting too. Would following a single illustrative ballot through successive counts make the point clearer than talking about candidates “getting your preferences”?

Discussion

5 community replies

A single ballot is a good teaching device. Label it illustrative and show which continuing candidate it is counted for at each stage. Don’t add a second full vote while leaving the first one in place.

Use “next available preference” when the explanation gets beyond the first exclusion. Otherwise someone may assume the number 2 always receives the transfer even if that candidate has already been excluded.

Keep the House label visible. People often shorten an explanation after hearing it once, and “this is how all Australian counting works” would go beyond the source you linked.

Could a single-ballot demonstration make it sound as if one person’s rankings determine which candidate gets excluded next?

Show that the exclusion comes from the totals across all ballots, then trace what happens to your example ballot after that exclusion. The example illustrates a transfer; it does not supply the result of the whole count.

Join the discussion

More in Politics