Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does making a reservation mean a country has rejected the whole treaty?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our international-affairs reading group is trying to understand treaty reservations. One person treats a country joining with a reservation as accepting every obligation. Another says the reservation means it has rejected the treaty and its membership is just theatre. Both descriptions seem too sweeping to me.

The UN Treaty Collection's glossary describes a reservation as a state's declaration purporting to exclude or change the legal effect of particular treaty provisions for that state. It also explains that reservations face limits: a treaty may prohibit them or allow only certain ones, and they must not be incompatible with its object and purpose.

I can follow that definition without being able to judge a particular reservation's validity or importance. I also don't want the group to treat an exclusion as trivial just because the country has joined the wider agreement. One provision could matter a great deal to the argument we're having.

What should we look at before describing what a country has accepted? How would you keep the discussion focused on the actual scope and significance of a reservation, instead of either 'fully signed up' or 'rejected everything'?

Discussion

5 community replies

I'd put the actual reservation beside the provision it refers to. Without both texts, the group could spend the whole evening arguing about a label while imagining different obligations.

Separate what the reservation says it changes from whether that change is permitted. The glossary explains why those are different questions; it doesn't establish that any particular reservation is valid.

I'd ask each person to restate their claim narrowly. Does 'rejected' mean rejecting one obligation, the treaty's overall aim, or participation altogether? Those are different criticisms and need different support.

A summary listing the excluded provisions would help, but I wouldn't count clauses and assume a short list means a small concession. The practical importance of the provision is what I would want to discuss.

Exactly. A single provision might be central to the issue your group cares about. The list would locate the disagreement; it wouldn't settle its importance. I'd use it to ask what difference the reservation is claimed to make in practice.

Join the discussion

More in Politics