Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does Japan’s Emperor choose government policy because he appoints the Prime Minister?

Politics category photographPolitics

A member of our constitutional discussion pointed to the Emperor of Japan’s formal appointment of a Prime Minister as proof that he chooses the government’s political direction. I wasn’t sure how to explain the distinction between performing a constitutional act and choosing the policy it is being linked to.

The Constitution of Japan, published by the House of Representatives, says in Article 4 that the Emperor has no powers related to government. Article 6 provides for appointment of the Prime Minister as designated by the Diet.

Would it help to show “designates” and “appoints” as separate steps in our explanation? I want to describe Japan’s constitutional arrangement accurately without assuming the word “monarch” tells us the political powers of every monarchy.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the actors beside the verbs. Saying only “the Emperor appoints” leaves out the designation described in the same constitutional provision, which is central to your question.

A formal role can matter constitutionally without giving its holder the policy choice somebody is attributing to it. You don’t have to call the act meaningless to explain that distinction.

Avoid importing an account of another monarchy into this one. Start with the provisions for Japan and discuss comparisons only after the roles are clear.

If the Emperor is the person who performs the appointment, isn’t “he appoints the Prime Minister” still an accurate sentence?

Yes, but it is incomplete as evidence that he chooses the political direction. Include the constitutional condition that the Prime Minister is designated by the Diet. The fuller sentence preserves the formal appointment while identifying the separate designation.

Join the discussion

More in Politics