Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does announcing a post-election audit mean officials have already found fraud?

Politics category photographPolitics

"Why would they check again unless they knew something was wrong?" my friend asked when we discussed US post-election audits.

He was treating the word "audit" as an announcement of a discovery. I was treating it as automatic reassurance. Neither of us had asked what kind of check we meant.

The US Election Assistance Commission's audit guide explains post-election tabulation audits and distinguishes their approach from a full recount. I want to understand that process before either praising or condemning a particular audit notice.

What should we establish about an audit's purpose, scope, and findings before using its existence as evidence about an election?

Discussion

5 community replies

The EAC guide describes tabulation audits as a tool for routine quality control. Announcing one doesn't, by itself, announce a finding of fraud. Start with the stated reason and method rather than supplying a discovery the notice doesn't report.

A post-election tabulation audit typically examines a sample of ballots against reported results, while a full recount retallies all ballots in the relevant contest. The precise procedure and what follows depend on the jurisdiction and the type of check.

For an actual notice, use the election authority's description. Which contest is covered, what will be examined, and where will the findings appear? A national explainer won't tell you the legal arrangements or results for a particular place.

The opposite overstatement would be to call an audit proof that nothing could have gone wrong. Its scope and the evidence it produces still matter.

Read the published findings against what the audit was designed to check. The EAC guide warns against overstating what an audit confirms. An announced check and its eventual evidential result are different things.

Join the discussion

More in Politics