Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does an MP signing an early day motion mean the Commons voted for it?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic group's update says 'the Commons backed our cause', based on a list of signatures on an early day motion. I want to recognise the MPs who signed without turning their action into a vote by the whole House.

The Commons Library's explanation of early day motions says MPs can use them to express views and gather signatures from colleagues. They are rarely debated. A list of supporters therefore needs a different description from the result of a Commons vote.

Would you change the update to say that the named MPs signed the motion, or include more explanation of what that means? Some volunteers think the correction would belittle work they put into raising the issue. I don't want accuracy to sound like telling them nothing happened.

Discussion

5 community replies

'These MPs signed an early day motion supporting the cause' gives them credit for the action you can verify. I'd be happy with that as the main sentence.

Be careful with the names missing from the list too. The Library explains that some parliamentary roles conventionally don't sign EDMs. Absence from this list alone wouldn't establish opposition.

The volunteers' work can have value without the whole House having voted. I'd keep the account of how they raised the issue and correct the description of the response.

I'd rather hear what the group wants to happen next than see the signature count presented as the final achievement. Is this meant to lead to a question, a meeting or something else?

That would make a useful next paragraph. I'd still report the signatures accurately, then explain the group's next aim. The list can show support without having to stand in for a decision or a completed campaign.

Join the discussion

More in Politics