Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does an independent councillor have to be politically neutral?

Politics category photographPolitics

My neighbour said she wanted an independent councillor because "then they won't have political views." I asked how they would decide a contested budget without any.

She meant someone who wouldn't simply follow a party line. I had heard her as asking for someone with no priorities or opinions. Once we noticed that, we still had questions about how an independent representative might cooperate with other councillors and explain a vote.

For local elections in England, the Electoral Commission's nomination guidance distinguishes the Independent description from standing with an authorised party name or description.

What should we ask about a representative's approach without treating that ballot description as a guarantee of impartial judgement, or assuming party membership settles the quality of someone else's judgement?

Discussion

5 community replies

The nomination guidance concerns a ballot description. It distinguishes independent candidates from those authorised to use a registered party name or description. That isn't a statement that an independent candidate has no political priorities.

Ask how they would explain a difficult vote, handle disagreement, and work with others to get decisions made. Those questions can be put to every representative without deciding in advance that one label guarantees better answers.

Your neighbour's concern about following a line is understandable. Keep it specific: what freedom of judgement does she want, and how would she recognise it in practice? "No political views" doesn't describe that concern very well.

Cooperating with a party on one decision wouldn't, by itself, tell you everything about an independent councillor's relationship with it. Ask what the arrangement is rather than infer a permanent allegiance from one shared vote.

That would keep the enquiry fair. Look for an explanation of the particular cooperation and any ongoing agreement, while assessing the decision's reasons separately. Neither agreement with a party nor disagreement with it is a complete test of independence of judgement.

Join the discussion

More in Politics