Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Does an egg sinking in water tell me it's safe to eat?

Food category photographFood

My brother put an egg in water and said we could use it because it sank. He treats floating as bad and sinking as a safety certificate. I wanted to check that before using the test to decide which eggs stay in our fridge.

USDA explains floating in terms of an enlarged air cell, while the FDA notes that even fresh eggs with clean, uncracked shells may contain Salmonella. Buoyancy isn't a check for that contamination.

We're in the US. How would you replace the float-test rule with a routine based on the eggs' label, storage history and the actual handling and cooking guidance? I don't want a bowl of water to supply certainty it can't give.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the carton and the storage history available. FDA guidance calls for prompt refrigeration at 40°F or below and appropriate cooking. A result in a glass of water doesn't replace those steps.

Separate the two questions: age-related quality and food safety. A clue about age doesn't settle both.

Don't replace sinking with a promise that an egg which looks or smells normal must be safe. The FDA's warning about contamination in apparently fresh eggs is exactly why handling and cooking still matter.

Would you stop doing the float test entirely? It seems to be adding confidence more than useful information in your kitchen.

I would stop using it to make safety decisions. If someone is interested in the buoyancy demonstration, keep that interest separate from deciding what to eat. The label and handling guidance remain the basis for the meal.

Join the discussion

More in Food