Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Does an apple being crisp to eat mean it will keep its shape in a pie?

Food category photographFood

I have a bag of apples I enjoy eating raw, but the label doesn't name the variety. I was going to use them for a pie and assumed their crisp bite meant the slices would stay distinct when baked. My sister suggested checking that before building the whole dessert around them.

The recipe author's apple comparison shows substantial differences in cooked texture between varieties. It gives me a reason to look beyond whether I like an apple straight from the fruit bowl.

Would you try a small baking trial, choose a known variety for the pie or make something where a softer apple texture would suit the dish? I'd like to use what I have without promising a filling I haven't understood.

Discussion

5 community replies

The comparison is a reason to check the variety and its baking behaviour. Enjoying the raw texture doesn't establish how these particular slices will behave in the finished pie.

If you want to learn about this bag, follow a suitable small trial before committing all the pastry and fruit. Note what you actually observe rather than give the unknown variety a confident name from its colour.

If the pie is for a deadline, decide which matters more today: using these apples or getting a particular filling texture. You can give the fruit another suitable job without calling the purchase a mistake.

I'd mix the unknown apples with a firmer baking variety and hope for a balance.

Mixing varieties can be intentional, as the author discusses, but it doesn't identify what the unknown apples will do. Use known information or a trial when you want predictability instead of treating mixing as a cure for the uncertainty.

Join the discussion

More in Food