Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does a treaty's appearance in the UN Treaty Series mean the UN endorses it?

Politics category photographPolitics

Someone in our international-affairs group found an agreement in the UN Treaty Series and wanted to caption the link 'UN-approved deal'. I suggested saying it was registered with the UN, but that sounded to them like splitting hairs: why would the UN list something it hadn't approved?

The UN Treaty Collection's explanation of registration says acceptance for registration does not give an instrument treaty status if it doesn't already have that status, or amount to a Secretariat judgement about the instrument or a party's status. Registration isn't a seal of political approval.

We haven't examined the agreement's merits. I want to preserve the useful link without lending it authority it doesn't carry. Is 'registered and published in the UN Treaty Series' a fair description where that is what the entry shows, or should the caption also explain the limit?

Discussion

5 community replies

Change 'UN-approved' before sharing it. The registration explanation doesn't support that endorsement.

The entry is still useful. It gives your group a document to examine instead of relying only on somebody's summary. Removing an exaggerated caption doesn't make the source worthless.

I'd add a short limit if 'approved' has already been circulating: 'Registration is not UN endorsement.' Otherwise people may keep the original impression while overlooking the quieter replacement wording.

I'd worry about overcorrecting. If we stress that registration isn't endorsement, readers might hear that the agreement itself is dubious.

It could if you overstate it. Say what the entry establishes and what it doesn't. Whether the agreement is good, valid or effective needs its own assessment; the lack of an endorsement doesn't establish the opposite conclusion either.

Join the discussion

More in Politics