Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does a signed US executive order show that Congress approved the policy?

Politics category photographPolitics

In a family discussion about US government, my cousin points to a president's signature on an executive order as proof that Congress voted for the policy. I know the document is an official action, but I don't think that signature establishes a congressional vote.

The National Archives describes executive orders as documents through which the president manages federal government operations. USAGov's account of making a federal law describes a bill passing both chambers and going to the president. Those are different things to identify before arguing about support.

I'm not trying to decide whether any particular order is lawful or what it changes. I just want to avoid attributing approval to people whose votes we haven't checked. How would you make that correction without implying the executive order is meaningless? What would you look for before saying Congress backed the policy?

Discussion

5 community replies

I'd keep the correction narrow: the signature shows the president signed that executive order. It doesn't, by itself, show a vote by either chamber of Congress.

Ask whether your cousin has a bill number or a roll-call reference. There may be a separate congressional action relevant to the policy, but it needs its own evidence rather than being inferred from this signature.

Calling the document meaningless would be a distraction. You can take an official action seriously while asking who took it and what it actually directs.

I'd also check the date before circulating the order as an account of current policy. The Archives warns that the linked original text doesn't include later amendments.

That date check adds something useful. An original order can be evidence of what was issued at the time without settling its present status. I'd label the document's date and keep later changes separate from the question about congressional approval.

Join the discussion

More in Politics