Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Does a red line on a title plan prove that I must pay for our fence?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

My neighbour put a printed title plan on the table and tapped the red line. 'There you are. The fence is yours, so you need to replace it.'

We are in England and both want a deteriorating fence repaired. I hadn't agreed who should arrange or pay for the work. The HM Land Registry guidance on boundary misunderstandings says most title plans show general boundaries, and that ownership and maintenance responsibilities are not automatically settled by the line on a plan.

I don't know the answer for this fence. How can I ask to check the relevant documents and get appropriate advice if needed, without announcing that the responsibility must be his instead? I want to discuss a practical repair, but I don't want pointing at the printout to become an agreement that I will cover the whole bill.

Discussion

5 community replies

Say that the plan doesn't, by itself, establish the conclusion he is drawing. That leaves the actual responsibility open. You don't need to replace his confident answer with an equally unsupported answer in your favour.

The source also distinguishes maintenance responsibility from ownership. Check what the relevant documents actually say rather than assuming all those questions have one answer.

Keep the repair discussion separate from a promise about the whole bill. If you consider any interim agreement, make sure its meaning is clear and get legal advice where the implications are uncertain.

Would a quiet conversation about which documents you each have help before this becomes a discussion in the residents' group?

That seems a better starting point than inviting a neighbourhood vote on the red line. It may still need qualified advice, but it avoids turning other people's guesses into evidence about this particular fence.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours