Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Does a joke present count when the invitation says no gifts?

Funny category photographFunny

The invitation says no gifts. My homemade cardboard trophy is apparently trying to qualify as an exception.

I made it for a friend's birthday because it refers to a joke we both enjoy. Then her invitation arrived with a clear no-presents line. I keep telling myself the trophy is small, silly and already made, so perhaps it doesn't count.

I don't know whether she means no expensive things, no objects at all or simply no obligation. I can ask, but that will reveal part of the surprise. I also don't want to arrive with it and make her decide at the door whether to accept something she'd asked people not to bring.

How do I handle this without making my preferred definition of a gift do all the work?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what she means, accepting that the answer may include your trophy. Losing a little surprise is easier to manage than asking her to resolve the exception while you're handing it over.

Keep the question genuine: 'I've made a small joke item, but I'm happy to leave it at home. Would you prefer that?' Don't ask in a way that makes refusing sound like rejecting all the effort.

She may be avoiding possessions, attention or the whole gift exchange rather than a particular price. You don't yet know, so the object's size and cost can't settle her preference.

The fact that it is already made explains your attachment, but it doesn't answer the request on the invitation. You can enjoy having made it without deciding it must be delivered at this event.

Agreed. You can keep the trophy for now and ask about sharing it another time if you'd actually want to. Don't turn that possibility into an automatic delayed presentation she has to accept instead.

Join the discussion

More in Funny