Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Does a honing steel sharpen a knife that still won't cut well?

Food category photographFood

My plain-edged stainless chef's knife keeps sliding over tomato skins unless I press harder than I want to. My brother handed me a steel rod and said a few passes would sharpen it. He demonstrated; it still isn't cutting the way I expected.

I don't know whether the rod is a honing steel or an abrasive sharpener. I'd assumed all the long rods in kitchen drawers did the same thing. Before I buy another tool, I'd like to understand whether I'm asking the wrong tool to solve the problem.

Would you identify the knife and rod and check their instructions first, or take the knife to someone who can assess the edge? I'd rather learn a suitable routine than keep copying a fast demonstration I don't understand.

Discussion

5 community replies

Victorinox distinguishes honing from sharpening: honing mainly realigns an edge, while sharpening removes material to renew it. It also lists abrasive rods among sharpening tools. The shape of the tool alone doesn't tell you what it does, so identifying yours is a useful first step.

Ask your brother what tool he used before copying the demonstration. If neither of you can identify it, pause there.

Taking it for assessment is reasonable if you don't want knife maintenance to become a new hobby. Ask what service would be suitable and what it costs before agreeing to it. There isn't a requirement to own every tool yourself.

Do you want to learn to maintain the edge, or mainly to have a usable knife for dinner? Those lead to different next steps. A lesson may be worthwhile, but it shouldn't be assumed from one frustrating tomato.

You can do them at different times. Have the knife assessed for the immediate problem, then decide whether you want instruction with equipment suited to it. Getting help once doesn't commit you to a course or to replacing the knife.

Join the discussion

More in Food