Does a coalition compromise prove a campaign pledge was dishonest?
Politics"If they drop it in a coalition deal, they were lying when they promised it," my friend said over lunch.
I said I could imagine a defensible compromise. He heard that as permission for parties to promise anything and negotiate it away afterwards. I don't want that either. I care about whether a commitment was presented honestly and how a later trade-off is explained.
We weren't assessing a particular current agreement. We were arguing about whether compromise itself proves dishonesty. I couldn't see how the eventual outcome alone tells us everything about what was known, intended, or reasonably promised at the time.
What would you examine before deciding? I want room to judge a broken commitment firmly without treating every negotiated change as either inevitable or fraudulent.