Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Do I tell two friends they independently gave me the same mug?

Funny category photographFunny

'I saw this and thought of you,' my friend said.

So had another friend. I now own two identical mugs showing a penguin reading a newspaper. I like them both and have no urgent need to exchange either.

The first friend is visiting next week. I caught myself planning which mug should be visible, then realised I was inventing a level of exclusivity neither giver had requested.

Should I mention the coincidence as a funny sign that they know my taste, or leave it alone unless it comes up? I don't want either person to feel that a thoughtful choice has been reduced to the second penguin on the shelf.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can mention it lightly if it comes up: 'You both spotted exactly the sort of mug I'd enjoy.' That is true without ranking which gift was more thoughtful or who found it first.

There isn't a practical problem to solve if you like having both. You don't need to request exchanges just to make the gifts different. Decide what you want before assuming duplication requires a repair.

Keep the thanks attached to each person's actual gesture. They chose something for you independently. A matching object doesn't erase the separate attention behind it.

Neither friend has asked for exclusive ownership of the idea. Hiding one mug could turn a harmless coincidence into an ongoing task you created for yourself. Give them room to react without predicting hurt that hasn't happened.

If one feels disappointed, hear that kindly without pretending the other mug doesn't exist. You can still explain what you enjoy about their gift. Two penguins can share a shelf without you maintaining separate visiting hours.

Join the discussion

More in Funny