Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Do I have to share a family story before asking a public-policy question?

Politics category photographPolitics

I submitted a question for a civic forum about how a proposed service change would be evaluated. The moderator asked me to introduce it with something difficult my family had experienced, saying that would help the audience understand why it mattered. I hadn't offered a family account and don't want one discussed on stage.

I can make the question concrete: what will be measured, when will the results be reviewed, and what would count as a reason to change course? The moderator thinks that sounds too abstract without a personal example.

How would you hold the boundary while keeping the question useful? I don't object to other speakers choosing to tell their stories. I don't want a willingness to disclose private circumstances to become the test of whether my policy question deserves an answer.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can say, 'I'd like to keep my family circumstances private and ask the question as submitted.' The moderator can understand your boundary without receiving the story behind it.

Your question already gives the speaker something specific to answer. Measures, review dates and a response to disappointing results are concrete issues even without a personal introduction.

The moderator may be trying to make the event accessible rather than trying to pry. Acknowledge that aim, then offer a short explanation of the decision you want clarified.

Could a clearly labelled hypothetical example do the job? That might help listeners picture the question without pointing to a particular household.

Yes, if you want to use one. Keep it brief and identify it as an illustration, so it isn't presented as evidence of something that happened. It should help explain your question, not become another condition you have to satisfy before asking it.

Join the discussion

More in Politics