Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Do Germans directly elect the members of the Bundesrat?

Politics category photographPolitics

In a comparison of political systems, our group called Germany's Bundesrat 'a senate whose members are elected on a separate ballot'. The analogy helped someone picture a second body, but I think it supplied an electoral process that isn't there.

Article 51 of Germany's Basic Law, in the published English translation and the German provision, says the Bundesrat consists of members of the state governments, which appoint and recall them. That differs from directly electing people to separate Bundesrat seats.

Would you drop the senate analogy entirely, or keep it with that distinction made explicit? We don't need to settle a debate about the best system. We do need readers to understand who sits in this institution before comparing it with another one.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use 'members of the state governments, appointed by those governments'. It's concrete enough to replace the invented ballot.

The analogy may help with the idea that there is another institution involved, but it shouldn't do the work of explaining its membership. Once it implies a separate election, it is steering readers away from the answer.

I'd also avoid treating 'not directly elected to this body' as a complete judgement about accountability. That is a further discussion, not something the membership description settles on its own.

Could we simply call the members 'state delegates'? That is easier to fit in a small diagram.

You could, but add that they are members of the state governments. 'State delegates' alone might sound like any representatives a state chooses, which loses the feature your correction is meant to explain.

Join the discussion

More in Politics