Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Can working condition replace a recall check at our neighbours' sale?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

We are organising a small neighbours' yard sale in the US. One seller is bringing a portable heater. When I suggested checking the model against the recall database, he said we could switch it on and label it 'working' instead.

I haven't identified a recall affecting this heater. I am asking for a check before it is offered, rather than claiming it is defective. The CPSC's resale information includes people holding yard sales and recommends screening used products before resale.

The organiser says we are volunteers, not a testing laboratory, and doesn't want me to create a safety certificate for every object on the tables. I don't want that either. How can we agree a useful recall-checking step without presenting a quick switch-on test, or a database search, as a guarantee that an appliance is safe?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start by getting the identifying details from the heater rather than guessing from its appearance. The seller can help check those details against the official recall information. Turning it on would answer a different, much narrower question.

I'd use the CPSC's reseller guidance to agree what you will accept before the sale. If an item matches a recall, follow that notice and its remedy requirements. Don't improvise a clearance process because someone says the product has always worked for them.

The organiser is right to resist a homemade safety certificate. A recall check can be recorded as a recall check, with no wider promise attached. Avoid a sign that implies volunteers have approved the electrical safety of everything on the table.

Could each seller provide the product details and do the initial check, with uncertain items held back? That would share the work rather than leave you researching a pile of unidentified appliances on sale morning.

That seems practical, provided uncertainty actually means waiting rather than adding a 'buyer takes the risk' label. Agree the process now and give people the official guidance. The aim is to make better decisions about what to offer, not shift every decision to the buyer.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours