Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Can we keep a family remembrance dinner without serving the same main dish every year?

Food category photographFood

Our family marks my grandfather's birthday with his favourite stew. I value the gathering, but the stew isn't a meal I enjoy much. This year I suggested another dish he also liked. My aunt heard that as retiring the tradition altogether.

I hadn't explained that the date, stories and time together are the parts I most want to keep. For her, making that particular recipe is part of remembering him. Neither of us is inventing the connection, but we've been treating our different attachments as though only one can count.

How would you discuss the next dinner? I could offer another dish alongside a smaller stew, suggest choosing different food memories in different years or keep this meal and change the planning another time. I'd like the conversation to leave room for what the food means to both of us.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask which part of the ritual she'd most miss if the menu changed. Then explain what you want to keep too. The conversation will be clearer than arguing only about whether the stew tastes good.

Offer a concrete version of the gathering that preserves something important to each of you. If you propose two dishes, say what you're willing to make rather than create an extra cooking job by suggestion.

You don't have to criticise the recipe to say you'd enjoy another main. A food preference isn't a complete statement about the person you're remembering.

Could different relatives choose a meal associated with him in different years?

That could make the food part of sharing memories rather than a single permanent assignment. Ask whether people want that arrangement and who would cook. Your aunt may still want the stew included, so leave room to discuss its place.

Join the discussion

More in Food