Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can our voluntary civic newsletter close its comment section and still invite criticism?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our small civic newsletter publishes local policy discussions. The volunteers want to turn off public comments because nobody can reliably moderate them after each edition. We could still receive letters and publish selected responses in the next issue.

One contributor says closing comments would show we only want praise. Another says an unstaffed discussion space isn't a meaningful promise of participation. I think both are pointing to something real: criticism needs somewhere to go, and someone has to do the work.

For this voluntary newsletter, would a clearly explained letters route be an honest alternative, or too much control over what readers get to see? We aren't discussing an official government account or claiming a legal rule about comments.

Discussion

5 community replies

Don't advertise an open discussion if you can't support it. A stated letters process is more credible than a comment box nobody is responsible for checking.

Explain how letters are selected, including whether criticism of the newsletter itself is eligible. 'Send us your views' means little if every uncomfortable response disappears.

Consider the delay. A response printed next month can't correct a practical mistake for people who need the information today. Keep a separate way to report corrections promptly, even if general debate moves to letters.

The editors would still choose which criticism the audience sees. That's a real loss compared with readers being able to respond in the same place.

It is a loss, and the explanation should acknowledge it. Publish the selection approach and be candid about the capacity limit rather than describing letters as identical to open comments. You can choose a manageable format without claiming it offers every benefit of the one you're closing.

Join the discussion

More in Politics