Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can our association count unanswered emails as votes in favour?

Politics category photographPolitics

The secretary has sent our committee a draft response to a transport consultation: 'Unless I hear otherwise by Friday, I'll record everyone as supporting it.' We haven't agreed a rule for deciding positions by email.

I have read the draft, but I'm still waiting for an answer about delivery access before choosing a position. Other people may not have opened it. The secretary's frustration is understandable: chasing every committee member has delayed earlier responses, and this consultation has a deadline.

I could object just to stop silence being counted, but that would make me sound opposed to a response I may eventually support. How can we get a usable decision without turning 'hasn't replied' into 'agrees'? Would you make an exception for this deadline or insist on settling the voting method first?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can reply about the method without voting against the text. I'd say you're still considering the access point and don't consent to being recorded in favour merely because you haven't chosen yet.

The deadline matters, but so does what the association can honestly say about its support. A response approved by the people who actually replied might be possible under your rules; don't assume it is without checking them.

Has the secretary made clear what happens if there aren't enough replies to take a decision? That seems more useful than another reminder asking everyone to answer.

I'd consider an agreed no-objection process for small routine matters. Requiring a fresh affirmative answer to every minor action could make a volunteer committee impossible to run.

That could be useful if members agree its scope beforehand. I'd distinguish arranging an already approved activity from adopting a new position on a consultation. Otherwise 'routine' may end up meaning whatever the sender needs approved quickly.

Join the discussion

More in Politics