Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can I withdraw my question before our civic forum reads it aloud?

Politics category photographPolitics

I submitted a question to a voluntary civic forum about how public services communicate changes. I used a disagreement involving someone in my household as the example. Before the event, that person asked me not to share it, so I told the moderator to withdraw my question.

The moderator says the wider policy issue is worth discussing and the running order already includes it. They offered to remove my name but keep the story. I don't think anonymity alone fixes the problem: people in the room could recognise the circumstances.

I still want the communication issue raised. Could the moderator write a genuinely general question of their own, without the household details, or does that make my withdrawal meaningless? I'm trying to resolve an editorial choice at this event, rather than claim a particular legal right.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for the submitted wording and personal example to be removed. The moderator can care about the issue without needing that account of it. A general question about how notices reach people doesn't depend on your household being the exhibit.

Having a slot in the running order is a practical inconvenience, but it isn't a strong reason to keep recognisable details. The replacement could occupy the same slot if it can be written without pointing back to you.

I'd distinguish withdrawing your contribution from trying to prevent anyone discussing the subject. Tell the moderator you support an independently framed question. That gives them room to preserve the useful topic without presenting your story.

What if even a general question would make the room think of this household? In a small group, changing the wording may not do much.

Then removing the identifying details may still be insufficient. The moderator should consider dropping or postponing that item, especially if it would invite people to reconstruct the story. Keeping a topic in the programme isn't the only way to take it seriously.

Join the discussion

More in Politics