Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Can I use a 10-inch cake tin for a recipe written for an 8-inch tin?

Food category photographFood

I measured the tin after buying the ingredients: it's 10 inches across, while the recipe uses an 8-inch round tin. Both are metal and about the same depth. I'd assumed two extra inches would barely matter.

I want a single layer tall enough to split and fill. My sister says to pour the same batter in and use the same baking time. I haven't mixed it, so I can still choose a different recipe or borrow a tin. What should I compare before deciding? I don't mind a different-shaped cake, but a much thinner layer would change the cake I planned.

Discussion

5 community replies

Compare the base area, not just the difference in diameter. King Arthur's pan guide uses area and also checks depth. Using that method, a 10-inch circle has about 56% more base area than an 8-inch circle. The same batter would spread across that larger area, so equal height isn't a reasonable expectation.

Borrowing the specified tin would be my choice if splitting the layer is central to the plan. That's one straightforward change while the ingredients are still separate.

Don't compensate by doubling everything without checking. A larger pan isn't automatically twice the pan, and a new batter depth would also make the old timing a poor promise.

Would you enjoy the cake as a lower single layer with the filling served alongside? That could make the tin you own useful without turning today into a recipe-scaling exercise.

Only if that's a cake you actually want. The original aim was a split layer, so it's fair to borrow a tin instead of calling every compromise equally satisfying. Ask that question before the batter forces a quick decision.

Join the discussion

More in Food