Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Can I stay friends with both neighbours after their separation?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

Two neighbours have separated. I knew each of them before they became a couple, and I have continued having coffee with them separately. I don't pass on what either says about the breakup or give updates about the other's life.

One has now told me that continuing to see her ex makes my friendship with her feel false. I understand that meeting him may hurt, but ending a separate, longstanding friendship feels like more than I can promise. I also don't want to ask her for private details as though she has to present a case before I take her feelings seriously.

How can I be honest about keeping both friendships without giving a speech about being neutral? I would accept that she may want some distance from me. I just don't want my attempt to explain myself to sound like I am dismissing what she is going through.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her what you can honestly offer: a friendship with her that doesn't include reports about him, comparisons or pressure to meet. You can't promise that your other friendship won't hurt her, and she gets to decide whether she wants contact on those terms.

'I care about you, and I'm continuing a friendship I already had with him' is clearer than announcing neutrality. Neutral can sound like you have weighed the breakup and reached a verdict when that isn't what you are trying to say.

Don't turn every coffee into a declaration that you saw the other person too. That could make ordinary contact feel like a running score. Equally, don't invent cover stories if she asks directly. Privacy doesn't need a false account of your day.

I'd leave room for her to tell you something that changes how you understand the situation. You don't need to demand details, but a fixed promise to treat everything exactly the same could make it hard for her to raise something important later.

That is a helpful distinction. Keeping both friendships now doesn't require making an unconditional pledge about every future circumstance. You can listen if she chooses to share more while being honest about what you currently intend to do.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours