Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Can I read a prepared welcome without being told it doesn't come from the heart?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I agreed to welcome some new neighbours at a small gathering. I prepared a short paragraph with the things I wanted to say. The organiser has now asked me to leave the notes behind because an improvised welcome would be more heartfelt.

I get flustered when I improvise and lose the points I meant to make. Preparing the words is how I try to be thoughtful, rather than evidence that I don't mean them. I hadn't understood accepting the role as agreeing to speak without notes.

How can I explain that while leaving the organiser room to want a different format? I am happy to offer a warm reading. I am not comfortable promising a performance I don't think I can give.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the organiser what you are offering: a short welcome using prepared words. Clarify that before the gathering, so the decision isn't made while you are standing in front of everyone.

Ask what worries them about the notes. If the concern is length or tone, you may be able to address that without pretending preparation and sincerity are opposites.

You don't have to prove you care by making the task harder for yourself. The words you chose and the welcome you offer can carry that care.

If an unscripted format is essential to the organiser, could someone else speak, with your prepared contribution used only if you agree?

That leaves a practical choice. You can offer the part you are comfortable giving and let them choose another speaker if needed. It doesn't have to become a verdict on whether your welcome was sincere.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours