Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can I quote a US Supreme Court syllabus as though it were the Court's own opinion?

Politics category photographPolitics

I found a clear sentence in the syllabus at the start of a US Supreme Court decision. For our politics group's handout, I put it in quotation marks after 'The Court said'. A friend pointed out that the document labels this part as a summary, but it is on the Court's website, so I had assumed the attribution was safe.

The Court's explanation of its opinion materials says the Reporter of Decisions prepares the syllabus for readers and that it isn't part of the Court's opinion. That seems a reason to label the source more precisely, rather than discard a useful summary.

Would you attribute the sentence to the syllabus, or find the relevant passage in the opinion before quoting it? This is a general discussion handout; I don't want to present our reading as legal advice or turn an accessible summary into words attributed to the justices.

Discussion

5 community replies

Change the attribution at least. Being hosted on the Court's website doesn't make every part of the document the opinion itself.

The syllabus can help you find the relevant issue. If the handout is making a claim about the Court's reasoning, check the opinion passage that supports it rather than assuming the summary settles every qualification.

I'd keep the summary if it helps beginners, with a clear label and a link. 'Useful for readers' and 'part of the opinion' are different descriptions; the first can be true without the second.

Finding the passage could turn a small reading-group task into a lot of legal research. I'd hesitate to make that the price of using any summary.

It needn't be the price of using one. Attribute the summary accurately and limit the claim you make from it. If you can't check a disputed point in the opinion, say that the handout hasn't resolved it instead of presenting the summary as a definitive legal conclusion.

Join the discussion

More in Politics