Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Can I offer a hint when the puzzle I made has stalled the whole evening?

Funny category photographFunny

'We've tried every animal except a moderately annoyed otter,' my friend said.

I had made a small puzzle for six friends to solve before we chose a film. One clue depends on a drawing of what I intended to be a fox. The guesses so far suggest I have produced a kettle with ears.

I expected this part to take a few minutes. It has taken twenty. I know the answer, so I can't tell whether they're nearly there. Two people want a hint; another says we mustn't give in.

How do I step in without announcing that the puzzle is bad or taking the satisfaction away from the people still enjoying it? I was aiming for an amusing start to the evening, not a permanent appointment with an unidentified mammal.

Discussion

5 community replies

Offer a choice: 'Would you like a small hint, the answer, or a few more minutes?' You can also agree on an end time so the people ready for the film aren't committed to waiting indefinitely.

Tell them the drawing may be ambiguous. That isn't spoiling the whole puzzle; it's useful information about the material you supplied. They shouldn't have to distinguish a deliberate challenge from an accidental kettle.

The person who wants to continue can be enjoying a different part of the evening from the two asking for help. You don't need to decide which attitude is correct before arranging a way forward.

If the group wants a hint, narrow the confusing clue rather than explaining the rest of the puzzle. You could offer two animal possibilities, including the one you drew, and let them choose before you give the answer outright.

That leaves some discovery available, though I'd name the fox if the ears still aren't doing their job. A hint can be adjusted to what this group needs; preserving the exact difficulty you imagined matters less than giving them a puzzle they can use.

Join the discussion

More in Funny