Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Can I keep the tomato joke without derailing a bring-fruit request?

Funny category photographFunny

'Fruit for after lunch,' my host wrote.

I sent a picture of the cherry tomatoes I already had and asked whether they counted. She replied, 'I meant something for the fruit bowl, not another salad.'

The Canadian Food Inspection Agency's tomato biology document describes the tomato as a botanical berry. So the factual part of my joke has support. It doesn't tell me what my friend wants to serve.

The gathering is tomorrow. I can bring something that fits her plan and ask whether the tomatoes would be useful as well. Part of me still wants to defend a perfectly legitimate fruit that has wandered into the wrong course.

How do I keep this playful without turning a small contribution into a classification dispute she has to manage?

Discussion

5 community replies

Answer the meal request now: ask what she'd find useful for the fruit bowl and say whether you can bring it. Offer the tomatoes separately if you'd like. The host is coordinating a course, not asking you to demonstrate a category.

The CFIA document supports the botanical berry description. That fact can remain true while the host uses fruit in the ordinary meal-planning sense she has just explained. The practical question is which contribution she actually needs.

You could bring both only if she wants the extra tomatoes and you're happy to do it. Don't arrive with an additional dish as proof that your interpretation deserved a place on the table.

One last playful line could close the joke: 'Botany rests its case. What would you like for the bowl?' Then agree on what you will bring. Repeating the factual point after the request is clear could turn shared humour into extra coordination.

Let that be a closing line rather than the opening of another round. You can enjoy the tomato's classification without requiring your host to reorganise lunch around it. The fruit has support; the menu still needs an agreement.

Join the discussion

More in Funny