Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Can I keep my own present if I draw it at the gift exchange?

Funny category photographFunny

I wrapped a notebook with badly drawn pigeons on it for our friends' small gift exchange. Everyone picks a numbered parcel from the pile. I have picked mine.

We haven't opened them yet. I recognise the orange string because I spent ten minutes trying to make it look intentional. I actually like the notebook and would happily keep it.

My cousin says I should quietly put it back and choose again because getting your own present defeats the point. The host hasn't announced what happens in this situation, and I don't know whether anyone else has already done the same.

Is it odd to want to keep it? How do I handle the draw fairly without turning the moment into a committee hearing about a pigeon in a scarf?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the host, 'I've drawn my own parcel. Are we keeping those or drawing again?' That gives the organiser a chance to state the rule while everything is still wrapped. Your cousin's preference doesn't have to become a secret procedure.

Wanting the notebook isn't strange. You chose something you thought would be enjoyable, and it turns out you are among its audience. The question for the group is how to handle the draw, rather than whether you have failed at generosity.

I'd care more about everyone using the same approach than about which approach wins. Keeping the first draw and redrawing your own gift could both work for a casual exchange if the host makes the choice clear to the group.

You can say you are happy to keep it, but don't make the host defend that outcome on your behalf. If they ask you to draw again, let the notebook go. There may be a practical reason in their plan that you haven't heard.

Yes, 'I'm fine either way' would make this easier for the host, provided you mean it. You can enjoy the coincidence without bargaining to preserve it. The orange string has already made its contribution to the evening.

Join the discussion

More in Funny