Can I hold a neighbour's spare key without leaving my own key with her?
NeighboursI agreed to hold a neighbour's spare key so she could ask for help if she needed it and I was available. She has now offered to hold mine in return. I already have an arrangement for my own key and don't want to change it.
She says it feels odd that I am trusted with access to her home but won't make the arrangement mutual. I hadn't understood holding her key as an exchange, and I don't want to explain my household's private reasons in detail.
How can I decline without framing it as a personal judgment about her? I am still willing to hold hers on the terms we agreed. If she would prefer a different arrangement, I would hand it back, but I don't want that to sound like a threat to withdraw the favour.