Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

Can I give my friend her books back without reading them?

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend asked which of the three books she'd lent me I liked best. I said I was still getting through them. I haven't started any.

I accepted them because she was excited and I didn't want to say they didn't appeal to me. Now they're sitting by my door, and every conversation about returning them becomes another vague progress report.

She hasn't demanded a review or made the loan conditional on loving them. I've supplied that pressure myself.

Can I return them and say I haven't read them, or does that need a fuller explanation after several months? I don't want to spend another month holding her books hostage to a reading plan I don't actually have.

Discussion

5 community replies

Return the books. An honest “I haven't read them, and I shouldn't have kept saying I was getting through them” gives her a clearer answer than another estimated finish date.

You don't have to tell her why each title fails to appeal. Thank her for thinking of you without presenting the return as a review of her taste.

The awkwardness has grown partly because you keep treating possession of the books as evidence that you'll eventually become an enthusiastic reader of them. Giving them back can end that arrangement without ending the conversation between you.

Would keeping just one be a reasonable way to narrow an overambitious plan, if there is one the narrator still thinks they might genuinely enjoy?

Yes, if they actually want to read it and their friend is happy to lend it longer. But keeping one as a ceremonial promise would leave the same problem on a smaller shelf. Returning all three unread is available too.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions