Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Can I give a useful reaction to a friend's song without pretending to know music theory?

Funny category photographFunny

'What would you change?' my friend asked after playing me a song she'd made.

I knew which part I wanted to hear again. I didn't know how to give the technical advice she seemed to be inviting. I nearly borrowed a few impressive words I've heard other people use, although I wasn't sure they described anything I'd noticed.

She had asked me because she wanted a listener's reaction as well as encouragement. I don't want to answer with empty praise. I also don't want a confident suggestion to disguise the fact that I'm guessing.

How do I make my ordinary listening response useful without turning it into a pretend lesson? I would like to give her something more honest than a very solemn opinion about the bridge.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her what kind of reaction you can offer: what held your attention, what you wanted to hear again and where you lost track. Those can be personal observations without becoming technical instructions.

Refer to the particular moment rather than reaching for terminology you aren't sure of. 'I liked the part after that quieter bit' can begin a useful conversation even if she supplies the musical name for it.

Ask whether there is a specific question she wants a listener to answer. If she wants a technical assessment, be clear that you aren't offering that kind of expertise.

You can take time to listen again if you'd enjoy doing so. Don't promise a detailed review simply because your first reaction isn't fully formed.

Exactly. You can say you'd like another listen and then share what you actually notice. That leaves your response useful within its limits, without turning a friendly favour into a qualification you don't have.

Join the discussion

More in Funny