Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Can I bring bought food to a potluck when 'homemade only' wasn't in the invitation?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour invited us to a potluck with the message, 'Bring something to share.' I offered to bring bread and olives from a shop because I would be coming after work and wouldn't have time to cook.

She replied that she meant proper homemade contributions. I hadn't understood that as part of the invitation. She feels it is unfair for some people to spend time cooking while others simply buy something.

I would respect a gathering specifically organised around home cooking. I am less sure how to respond to that expectation being added after I accepted. How can I ask whether my contribution is welcome without dismissing the work others plan to do? I don't want to pretend I made the food or turn a supper into an argument about whose time counts.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask whether this is intended to be a homemade-food event or a shared supper with different kinds of contributions. Once that is clear, you can decide whether you can take part on those terms.

Acknowledge that people are planning to cook, while explaining that you offered bought food honestly because of the time available. There isn't a need to prove that your workday was more demanding than their preparation.

I would avoid disguising the contribution or inventing a story about cooking it earlier. If she doesn't want bought food at this particular event, a clear answer is more useful than a meal built on different assumptions.

Would you want to offer help with clearing up as your contribution instead? That could be another way to share the work if it fits the evening.

Offer that only if you want to and it is agreed in advance. Bringing bought food shouldn't quietly commit you to an additional job as proof of effort. Equally, you can decline an event whose intended format doesn't fit what you can offer.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours