Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

Can I ask to return a treasured plant when I can't look after it as well as my friend hoped?

Relationships category photographRelationships

My friend gave me a cutting from her late grandmother's plant. I knew it mattered to her, but I hadn't realised she would want regular photographs of how it was doing. It now looks unhealthy, and I've started avoiding the requests because I feel ashamed.

I don't want to send an old photo or pretend it is thriving. I also don't want to keep accepting responsibility for something she treats as a piece of family history when I'm not managing it well.

How do I tell her and ask whether she wants it back without making the gift sound unwelcome?

Discussion

5 community replies

Send an honest update before another request goes unanswered. Describe what you've noticed and say that you haven't managed its care as you hoped. You don't need to offer a confident explanation of what is wrong with it.

Ask whether she would like it back rather than assuming that returning it is the answer she wants. She may be attached to this particular cutting, or she may have understood giving it away differently from how you now imagine it.

You can appreciate why she gave it to you and still be honest about the responsibility you want to take on. The plant's condition doesn't need to become an assessment of whether you care about her.

I'd discuss the regular photographs as well as the plant. If the updates make the gift feel like an ongoing assignment, explain that kindly. Don't promise a fresh reporting routine just to soften the current conversation.

Otherwise the immediate update could resolve while the same pressure remains. You can ask what the photographs mean to her, then agree only to a kind of contact you actually want rather than another obligation you will start avoiding.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships