Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Can I ask for the final jigsaw piece back after giving it away as a prize?

Funny category photographFunny

'It's my medal,' my nephew said, holding up the last piece of our jigsaw.

He had helped patiently through a difficult stretch. I jokingly awarded him the final piece before we put it in. I said he could keep it. He took the prize home.

The picture now has one bright hole near the middle. I realise I would quite like to finish it and display it for a little while. My nephew is pleased with his tiny medal and has made a place for it beside his other treasures.

Can I offer him another token and ask for the piece back, or should I accept that I gave away the ending? The puzzle is complete everywhere except the part I turned into an award.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can ask whether he'd like to exchange it, but make the request a real choice. You told him he could keep it. Explain that you hadn't thought through wanting to display the whole picture, rather than saying he misunderstood what a prize meant.

Talk with his parent about how to make the request clear and low pressure. Don't ask the parent to secretly return it so you can avoid a disappointed response from your nephew. That would change the gift while leaving him out of the decision.

Another token may mean less to him than the exact piece he helped earn. Ask what he likes about it before assuming a larger or shinier substitute would improve the offer. The smallness may be part of its appeal.

You can also keep the hole as part of the story. If displaying a perfect picture is a preference rather than a pressing need, leaving the prize alone may be the easier way to respect the decision you already made.

If you ask and he wants to keep it, let the answer stand. You could ask separately about borrowing it briefly for a picture only if that would genuinely help and he is happy with it. The medal doesn't have to become a contest that an adult eventually wins.

Join the discussion

More in Funny