Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Can I ask a neighbour to stop joking about a mug I broke after I replaced it?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I dropped and broke a neighbour's mug while borrowing it. I apologised and replaced it with the copy we agreed on. I understand why she might still be cautious about lending things to me.

Now she introduces me to new people with jokes about hiding the crockery. I laughed the first time, but it keeps becoming the story attached to my name. When I asked whether we could retire it, she said, 'You did break it.'

I am not disputing that or asking to borrow more things. How can I ask for the public joke to stop without suggesting that replacing the mug should have bought instant trust or erased the accident?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for the particular change: please stop using the mug story when introducing you. That is different from demanding that she lend you things again.

Replacing the mug was a practical repair. It doesn't decide when she feels comfortable lending, but her caution also doesn't require repeated public jokes.

I'd avoid reopening the whole question of whether the accident mattered. Acknowledge it once and explain what the recurring introduction is doing to an otherwise ordinary conversation.

She may have understood your first laugh as permission to keep using the joke. Tell her that it has stopped being enjoyable, rather than assuming she knew all along.

That is fair. 'I know I laughed at first; I'd like us to leave it out now' owns the earlier reaction without making it permanent permission. You can ask for that while accepting that the mug was genuinely broken.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours