Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can Congress override a US president’s veto with a simple majority?

Politics category photographPolitics

In a discussion exercise, our group gave a bill more yes votes than no votes in both houses of the US Congress. Then we added a presidential veto and assumed another ordinary majority vote would settle it.

The National Archives’ Constitution questions and answers explains that Congress can override a presidential veto with a two-thirds majority in both houses. We are discussing a bill returned to Congress with a veto, not trying to cover every possible way a bill can fail to become law.

How should I amend the exercise so people see why passing a bill and overriding a veto involve different thresholds? I’d like to use clearly illustrative totals, but I don’t want an easy arithmetic example to hide the requirement for a separate result in each chamber.

Discussion

5 community replies

Show the House result and the Senate result on separate lines. A combined total can look comfortably above a threshold while one chamber has not met its own requirement.

Label the second vote “override” and state the threshold before giving the illustrative numbers. Otherwise participants may carry the original ordinary-majority rule into it without noticing.

Don’t imply that sufficient votes are guaranteed just because the bill passed earlier. The exercise should ask whether each new result meets the override rule, not assume the earlier coalition answers it.

Could a very simplified exercise make the process look purely mechanical, when members’ political choices are the hard part?

Keep the arithmetic modest, then discuss why members might choose different positions on an override. Understanding the threshold gives that political discussion a sound starting point; it needn’t pretend to explain every decision.

Join the discussion

More in Politics