Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Can bread flour make useful cookies, or is it only for bread?

Food category photographFood

The only flour in the cupboard is bread flour, and I want to make chewy cookies. My brother said using it would be a mistake because cookies aren't bread. I was about to buy another bag, then wondered whether the name was a rule about where it can be used.

I'm still choosing the recipe. Would you look for a cookie recipe developed for bread flour, use an author's substitution guidance or keep to all-purpose flour for a familiar result? I'm happy to choose a different texture; I just don't want to assume every flour substitution is invisible.

Discussion

5 community replies

King Arthur's cookie comparison uses bread flour in cookies and describes a chewier result from its higher protein and water retention. The name isn't a prohibition. A recipe designed for that flour is a sensible way to pursue the texture you say you want.

Choose on the result rather than on proving your brother wrong. If chewy is the aim, you have a useful lead. If you wanted a delicate, crisp cookie, the same lead might not be the one to follow.

Read the complete cookie recipe before buying another flour. Check what the bag you own can already do.

Would you make a small batch first rather than commit all the ingredients to a texture you haven't chosen before?

Yes, if the recipe supports that batch size or you scale it carefully. A small batch should still follow a coherent formula. It can tell you whether you like those cookies without becoming an uncontrolled collection of substitutions.

Join the discussion

More in Food