Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can a poll published after a debate tell us how people reacted to that debate?

Politics category photographPolitics

I'm putting together a reading-group handout and have invented a simple example to test a claim: a televised debate happens on Wednesday, a poll is published on Friday, but its interviews all took place on Monday and Tuesday. Someone wants the caption to say, 'Friday's poll shows the debate changed minds.'

The publication date makes that sound plausible at a glance. But the people were interviewed before the event. AAPOR's disclosure standards include the dates of data collection among the information to disclose.

In this illustrative example, I would say the poll describes views gathered before the debate and cannot establish a response to it. Would you remove the debate claim completely, or keep the poll beside the debate report with a clear date label? I don't want layout to suggest a causal link the wording has withdrawn.

Discussion

5 community replies

Remove the reaction claim. A Friday release doesn't move Monday's interviews forward in time. If the poll stays, put the interview dates where a reader can see them before making the connection.

It could still be useful as a picture of views before the debate. That gives it a clear purpose in the handout without asking it to measure something that hadn't happened yet.

Even interviews conducted afterward wouldn't, by timing alone, establish that the debate caused a change. For this example, though, the earlier fieldwork is enough to rule out the proposed caption.

What if the handout has very little space and readers expect the latest published poll? I'd be reluctant to leave it out just because it can't answer the debate question.

You can keep it as the latest release while labelling the earlier fieldwork. I'd give it a separate paragraph or box so 'latest published' doesn't quietly become 'measured after the debate' when someone scans the page.

Join the discussion

More in Politics