Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can a civil servant explain government policy without endorsing the governing party?

Politics category photographPolitics

A career civil servant from a UK government department is coming to our workshop to explain a service change. One member wants to open by asking which party the guest voted for. He thinks we can't assess the explanation without knowing the speaker's political loyalties. I think that could derail the questions about the change itself.

The Civil Service Code says civil servants support the government of the day while maintaining political impartiality. It also requires truthful presentation of facts and evidence-based advice. Explaining a policy therefore shouldn't automatically be treated as a personal party endorsement, or as a reason to stop examining the explanation.

I'd rather ask what evidence supports the change, what practical problems have been considered, and who is responsible for the decision. How can I suggest that without sounding as though I'm shielding the guest from criticism? I want a demanding discussion about their work, not an argument about their ballot.

Discussion

5 community replies

'What evidence supports the change?' sounds more useful than asking who the guest voted for. A party label wouldn't tell you whether the explanation answers the service problem.

The code's honesty and objectivity requirements matter here too. Political impartiality doesn't mean inconvenient facts should be left out of an explanation. You can ask directly about a gap without asking for a party preference.

I'd tell the guest beforehand what the workshop is trying to understand. That gives them a chance to clarify what they can address and prevents the first few minutes becoming a dispute about why they came.

Who actually chose the policy, and who can change it? I wouldn't want a polite meeting that directs every difficult question to someone who isn't there.

That is worth establishing at the start. The guest could be asked to distinguish their explanation of implementation from the decisions made elsewhere, and identify where unanswered policy questions should go. You can then see what remains unresolved rather than treating their attendance as the whole response.

Join the discussion

More in Politics