Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Are the ICJ and ICC two names for the same court in The Hague?

Politics category photographPolitics

I used ICJ and ICC interchangeably in notes for our international-affairs group. A member asked why a paragraph about a dispute between states had become a sentence about putting an individual on trial.

I had treated the shared location and similar initials as more important than the different institutions. The UN Library's ICJ guide describes the court's functions and records. We aren't assessing a particular current case; we're trying to correct the map we would use to read one.

How should we distinguish the courts before discussing what any particular proceeding might establish? I don't want an acronym correction to leave the same mistaken idea about who is being judged and what kind of decision is possible.

Discussion

5 community replies

They are different courts. The ICJ deals with legal disputes between states and does not try individuals or issue criminal convictions. The UN's ICC explanation describes that court as investigating and prosecuting individuals for the gravest international crimes. Neither name is interchangeable with the other.

For each item in your notes, identify the court, the actual document, who the proceedings concern, and the procedural stage. A general account of an institution won't tell you what a particular document has decided.

Be precise about the type of proceeding as well as the name. The UN Library guide also describes the ICJ's advisory role. A note about international courts shouldn't make every document sound like a criminal trial or a final ruling on a state dispute.

I'd resist answering the correction with "then the other court will deal with it." That still assumes every allegation can simply be redirected to a different institution.

Exactly. Correct the institution first, then check the jurisdiction and proceeding relevant to the actual matter. A broad distinction between states and individuals is a starting point, not a conclusion that either court must hear or resolve a particular case.

Join the discussion

More in Politics