Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Are small powerful magnets a suitable party-bag gift just because the children aren't toddlers?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour has a set of tiny high-powered magnetic balls sold as an adult desk toy. She wants to divide the set into little bags for children at a neighbourhood party. I offered to help assemble the bags before I knew what would go in them.

When I raised a concern, she said these were school-age children, old enough to know not to swallow things. The magnets haven't been handed out and no child has swallowed one.

The CPSC's magnet-safety guidance warns that high-powered magnets pose serious risks to children from toddlers through teens. That makes me unwilling to put these loose balls into the children's bags. I am not claiming that I have tested this product or worked out its legal status.

How do I ask her to change the plan without making her feel that I think she doesn't care about the children? I would help with a different gift, but I don't want my offer to become a safety endorsement of whatever replaces it.

Discussion

5 community replies

The older-children argument is the point to address directly: the CPSC warning includes teens. Share it and ask her to leave these magnets out of the children's bags. There is no need to turn the conversation into a judgment about how caring she is.

Be specific about this proposed gift. You are concerned about loose, small, high-powered magnets from an adult desk set. Keeping the explanation precise is more useful than announcing that every object with a magnet is the same.

Keep the magnets separate from the bags while you agree what to do. If ingestion is ever suspected, CPSC advises immediate medical attention. This is a chance to change the plan before there is an incident.

The bags could go ahead without this item while another gift is considered. Would that remove the feeling that all her preparation is being rejected?

Leaving the item out would let the rest of the preparation continue. Agree any replacement separately, with appropriate product information for the intended children, rather than treating your willingness to assemble the bags as approval of an unseen substitute.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours