Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Are potato flour and potato starch the same ingredient for bread?

Food category photographFood

My bread recipe calls for potato flour. The packet in the cupboard says potato starch. I nearly treated the words as two names for the same powder, then stopped before measuring it into the dough.

King Arthur's substitution guide distinguishes flour made from whole potatoes from extracted starch. It also discusses substitutions in yeast bread, so this isn't simply a choice between pretending they're identical and abandoning the loaf.

Would you use the author's specific substitution directions or choose a recipe written for the packet you have? I want to preserve the soft bread I planned while knowing what adjustment I'm actually making.

Discussion

5 community replies

Read the substitution section for yeast bread, including the amount and the effect the author expects. The guide allows a route between these ingredients in that context; it doesn't say the two products are identical in every use.

Keep the full packet name in your notes. Copying only potato loses the distinction between the ingredients.

I'd follow a stated adaptation rather than invent a ratio from how similar the powders look. You caught the question before mixing, which is the easy point to resolve it.

If you like the result, would you keep making that version instead of buying another specialist ingredient?

Certainly. Record it as the version using potato starch and the directions you followed. That gives you something repeatable without rewriting the ingredient's name and forgetting why the method worked.

Join the discussion

More in Food